Meet PASTEL Cookies, the new name of the Finger Lakes Cookie Co.!

At PASTEL, We obsess to create the highest quality cookies and baked goods for our customers. Never frozen and always made from scratch, we offer a delicious experience with every bite.

The original Finger Lakes Cookie Co. started in 2016 in Geneseo, NY. In 2022, the brand was renamed PASTEL, a name fitting for cookies and baked goods that are airy, soft, sweet, and define simple perfection.

Explore our entire range of flavors and more sweet baked treats at PASTEL Cookies!

Our Holiday Options

Holiday M&M Chocolate Chip: Delicious Ghirardelli M&M Chocolate Chip cookies.

Triple Chocolate with Peppermint Drizzle: A holiday treat featuring a peppermint infusion to this chocolate cookie delight.

Almond Holiday: An almond cookie with red and green sprinkles. Festive AND delicious!

Our Regularly Featured Options

Triple Chocolate: Decadent chocolate cookie made with three types of chocolate: unsweetened cocoa, dark chocolate, and semi-sweet chocolate chips.

Triple Chocolate with M&Ms: Decadent chocolate cookie made with three types of chocolate: unsweetened cocoa, dark chocolate, semi-sweet chocolate chips and plain M&M's.

Lemon Crack: The lemon earns new found respect with this delicious, gourmet cookie made with real lemon zest and other natural goodness that have you forgetting making lemonade if life deals you a lemon.

Molasses Crinkle: This classic cookie has a beautiful twist as they are sweetened with brown sugar and molasses and spiced with cloves, cinnamon and ginger.

Oatmeal Sea Salt Caramel: These uniquely decadent cookies are chewy from the oatmeal, sweet from the caramel bits, and salty from the sea salt sprinkled on top.

Oatmeal Scotchie: Soft and chewy oatmeal scotchies are cinnamon-spiced, sweetened with brown sugar, packed with oats, and loaded with butterscotch chips.

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip: Our classic oatmeal with Ghiradelli chocolate chips.

Chocolate Chip: Made with Ghiradelli chocolate chips, these classic favorites have an exceptional soft, yet slightly crunchy texture.

Chocolate Chip w/ M&Ms: Specialty chocolate chip featuring M&Ms

Chocolate Chip w/ Macadamia Nuts: Specialty chocolate chip featuring macadamia nuts.

Almond Funfetti: These almond sugar cookies are a delight to look at, but more importantly, to eat. Great for the holidays.

Oatmeal: The traditional oatmeal cookie is a standard-bearer, with this delicious cookie satisfying the most discerning oatmeal cookie lover.

Deer Run Black Wine Cookie: A decadent chocolate brownie cookie created with our local Deer Run Winery Max Black sweet red wine. Add some peanut butter chips to the mix for a heavenly chocolate/peanut butter pairing, roll the whole thing in powdered sugar, and bake to a perfect crinkled goodness.

Fully Loaded Cookie: Gluten Free! A flourless peanut butter oatmeal cookie loaded with M&Ms and chocolate chips.

Skaneateles Sugar Shack French Toast: Made with locally tapped, 100% real maple syrup, these cookies will give new meaning to "breakfast anytime".

Peanut Butter: The best peanut butter cookies have everything -- a chewy texture, crisp edges, and the richness of all natural peanut butter. The perfect peanut butter cookie!

Salted Butterscotch Pretzel: Browned Butter adds depth to the flavor to this cookie recipe while the butterscotch and chocolate chips keep things perfectly sweet!

S'Mores: Ghiradelli Chocolate chips, graham crackers, and marshmallows will have you by the fire and all smiles